my thermostat mod
for years i have been trying to solve heat issues on old "gerty"
things took a turn for the worse just the other day whilst riding home from work ...the old girl decided to spit some fluid out and turn on the fan by herself and heading way up to 100 c on the guages (hardly ever seen that before )
well all things came to a point of realization that i better do something about it ..now
we had tested the thermostat some while ago ( alby the amazing ) ....after fitting the 3 core radiator ...some good results followed ,,,but never really solidly stable ...with an every now and then high running temperature ...i know shes not leaking fluid from anywhere important ....been looking for things for ages ...and never need to top up the fluids as a general rule of thumb ...but every now and the the poor old darling shows me she is getting hot under the collar .
folks were looking for the right gasket (donut seal ) for the thermostat to fit in the radiator in another thread on the forum ...and i had done some previous investigation towards this ...
"neds" post from long ago confirmed that the toyota thermostat fitted up nicely ,but the seal was not a good fit .
but new to the mix was a newly designed and released "hi flow option" thermostat ...and you guessed it, a release appropriatly with a version for the old "rolla " (toyota corolla - rolla )
hmm ...his looks interesting .
the apature was about 5mm wider across the diameter of the working valve than the bmw ...and maybe 6 or so wider than the original..."works good" and nearly forever ... toyota standard replacement .
so i grabed the "indicated " as compatible seal as well ...even though i knew it wasnt going to fit square ...from neds post
and a couple of the other ones i had investigated a long while back (making a possibility of at least three options that may or may not fit in that widdle hole )
the recommended ,. about $ 2.50 at 50mm od x 6.5mm ...
the next size up , but with known square section , about $3.45 a tad over 50 mm od x 4.?mm ...(i could always cut some length out of it and sit it in there with some down preasure from the retaining cap with a dab of high temp silicon just for giggles) .
the other option was a tiny bit smaller $11.50 (ripoff bastards )...but would stretch to fit at 48mm od x 4.? mm
the recommended was too wide in the hole ...the cut out of the profile left about 2.0 2.5mm of outer wall to the od ...i had thought this is never going to fit round te circumfrence and stay at 50mm
which prooved correct ...the slight stretch made the thing at least 1mm bigger than the hole it was suposed to fit ...besides the profile was all wrong for the radiator , in this application with a roundish look and the width was about 6.3mm after application to the thermostat .
the rolla has a standard bell type housing and could use the extra gap as takeup, i guess the housing internals was about 55 mm overall id ...
the 48mm one was a perfect fit with a width of about 4.3 mm ...but with the slight stretch wants to lie either inside or outside the radius (high or low of the edge )
lets see if this fits !!!
i worked the seal down towards the venting of the radiator core first , so that the edge would sit correctly then slowly droped the rest in the hole to a perfect sized fit...just touching the edges all the way around
after applying the retension assembly i checked for compression , would it be too much
no not at all , i could screw the screws alamost down to about 1.5 mm left , by hand lightly before meeting some resistance ,,,sweet ! this will let the front seal of the retainer do its job properly against the body of the housing .
one of the things i did notice however was the rear bypass blocking plate was slightly smaller than the original bmw thing , and that the depth between the front flange and the bypass vent restrictor was a few mm deeper into the void on the high flow thermostat.
i measured the distances carefully and did a little figuring out ...the new one would only leave about 3-4mm of bypass fluid flow .....not bad, but too close for me ...i wanted something like 6- 10 mm of opening, after seeing the reaction of the thermostas at temperature
this may have been important ,, so i experimented with the actuation of the thrmostat whist at temperature
i could see that the new device threw further into the housing and closing off the bypass quicker ...maybe not so good , and that the spring tensioned bypass restrictor could offer a little too much back pressure , before opening fully . (as i suspect the bmw one was failing to do on a regular basis and letting uncooled fluid circuluate through the system )
i noticed how much change there was between closed and open distances on both the bmw one and the new device ,
hmm ..flared copper ,,, i wonder ,,,yep cut it off at the flare to allow me to a modify it a little ,
so cut off about flush with the flare of the rear retainer , i cut a few slots about 5 mm into the length of the flange , the aim was to peen these over and retian the blocking plate again , also i cut about 5mm out of the spring to match the relative tensions that i thought would work out right without presenting too much pressure against the opening mechanism
the rear plate although smaller would still do the job admirably after measuring the bypass port
dully filled primed and no leaks with new fluid , test ride ....
sweet ....it didnt skyrocket at all, just sat comfortably about 86-89c with a little ride round the block ...
i stopped for a while after warming to let her tickover ..... a sure temperature rise exersize ...no rise at all ...yippee
results of a 600k plus ride around the loop ...amazing
after a 150 k freeway ride up near 4.5 k revs ..with some spirited back roads towards the end (higher revs ...grin) and arrival at bryon bay ... a real traffic jam was encountered as usuall about 3 kilometers out of the small town on market day .
..20 plus minutes idling away, then mooving forward a car length ...normally sure to tweek me to hit the manual over ride of the fan to extinguish flames from under the tank sorta stuff .........no ...not a budge cool and quiet was the old girl ...maybe nudging 91 c ....no problem at all ..
another 250 k across mountans ,,,hills and dale had me up in stanthorpe to visit rick
still no issues ...that temperature guage was stuck there ...never budging from a few degrees of moovement ....in fact riding at about 80 k/per hour has it the warmest ...as speed increases the temperature drops slightly ...what the ....?!!!
still some 200 odd kilometres from home the night ride ran well ...down the big hill
i can see now why the 2 core radiator was used on all susequent versions of the k after 85 ...three cores just isnt needed at all ...and in cooler climates ....does the thermostat ever come up to full working temperature ? left me wondering !!!!
if your up for a little grubby hands on playing ...do this mod ... it isnt particually hard to do ...it wont cost the earth ...and i recon will come out cheeper than buying "original" from here or overseas .......and works really well .
total cost (at retail) including bits i was never going to use ...$54.00
i really wonder should we start a ..."this works for me, mod" type topic .... that many could contribute to ????
there are so many good and reliable "known solves" already in this forum from many advanced and knowledgeable contributors .
what do you think ?